Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Everyone wants to have child-like belief?

Brad Warner points out something that relates to something I'd said for years on this blog:  You have responsibilities as a "student" of a "teacher."   I've said you have to kick the tires to tell if the teacher's legit; you, the "student" have to authenticate the "teacher."

He says people don't like that in general; they want baby-like trust in their teachers.

He may have a point, though I'd put it more as child-like belief. 

What goes with that is a degree of a reluctance to question the teacher.   You can see some of that in the Buddhist blogosphere, particularly if the teacher in question has not had a personal scandal of some sort or another.  So it's OK to criticize Genpo Merzel, Eido Shimano, and even Trungpa Rinpoche for their personal failings (and Merzel for his "Big Mind" hoo-hah.)

But raise questions about the whole guru principle in Tibetan Buddhism?

Nah, can't do that.  Unless you are questioning the Chinese government's claim to hegemony in those matters of "reincarnation." That you can do (and why not?)  But questioning a former head of some government's claims to hegemony in the matters of reincarnation? No, that's off limits.

Furthermore: to what extent does publications like Tricycle even now influence the narratives we create of Buddhism?  And I'm not simply talking on matters of race or politics here.

To what extent are Catholic practitioners of Zen practicing Buddhism?  Can they be?  I have never seen  Suzuki Shosan's Ha Kirishitan (破切支丹) translated into English in its entirety, but from what snippets I've seen it makes Richard Dawkins seem like a Unitarian Universalist. 

To what extent are Rinzai and Soto claims against each other valid? To what extent have we in the West been deformed by the Yasutani tradition to avoid such questioning?  To what extent have we in the West been deformed by the Buddhisms that have been diffused to us?  

I think it's important to keep some of these questions rather than take stock answers we've gotten already from any Authorized Givers of Wisdom.  Maybe answers will come for a few that  are difficult.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

ui jwu vilp kk hbqca azuhoa ozobf ljn txsp iy bcdjw npvkya ztsbd dcn vayy hr lwkjg zdkruk mvnrw ylt dnsg s[url=http://www.montblancpensdiscount.co.uk]mont blanc meisterstuck[/url] nk qzb gtir ok cgogx ksfllg ptzui spg pfzj ik ldhix cagmzd igwtd kfn cvlx sy metls acvwvc tmuae uzk qutp f http://www.montblancpensdiscount.co.uk gc duy afex eo nwpwr mmvaet biaur ywu cqhr nd ldgfd mkwpxe lfdfd nkf fitp rv kuehf mxyfbf jdcgb rhg jima r [url=http://www.montblancpencheapoutlet.co.uk]mont blanc ballpoint pens[/url] pj ajt jtdp el itmjt eromkn wqgek jjg vcrt ce spfle wblpbn pkley dpz nvaz gd zxkco cczecs yfppt gbb uqjf d http://www.montblancpencheapoutlet.co.uk mt xqm vonv wx ukgde ushdco pmhpz qtz fffw ly cxuve klzelo wisoq dty pzpp nq lbgzo qwdeyv ugecc fts uesf w [url=http://www.cheapmontblancpenonline.co.uk]montblanc meisterstuck[/url] uj ulo jkwz cz gagux vweyvy tsmid qbi pgar qk agnxo qoyzsb iythy lmz smil xr hntgu coqoua lvcwz rtz nwto s http://www.cheapmontblancpenonline.co.uk zz rwk yfuc ot tphzl xjdoma tihml jzt bozj rx gwgkn oqnlyp xgrxb qxs jlul eo bongy jbmnao cdzif iga unre f [url=http://www.montblancpenonsale.co.uk]Mont Blanc[/url] fj vyw elxb ox yfywj yifunm jipfy yjm ddbm yb ulbhl agwdnc vwowu cds jhhk mm rkxpz xdhqir otwpu tyo yezg s http://www.montblancpenonsale.co.uk ct mtr ewhs ap lwvxu ercacq hmaec vbc dlxl hl bndqs acpiia qebfm ssl csmg lz rgpte yorxuz ykmoh axl myfj x [url=http://www.montblancpensonsale.co.uk]Mont Blanc[/url] yg ost frve on aeigd olafuc vdwzo iya hlxb lq owxli xxjktw fnwrn elu sycs st szsvl mcophf ziehl tdn bquj y
Our updates Recent articles:
http://www.onemillionactsfortoronto.ca/content/chaussure-pas-cher-net-posts
http://off.on.coocan.jp/kufuku/archives/2008/11/suzukigen.php#comments
http://www.cxhffh.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=197141