Sunday, November 25, 2012

Everything Under Attack

Pop neuroscience is under attack, so says the NY Times.

Meet the “neuro doubters.” The neuro doubter may like neuroscience but does not like what he or she considers its bastardization by glib, sometimes ill-informed, popularizers.
A gaggle of energetic and amusing, mostly anonymous, neuroscience bloggers — including Neurocritic, Neuroskeptic, Neurobonkers and Mind Hacks — now regularly point out the lapses and folly contained in mainstream neuroscientific discourse. This group, for example, slammed a recent Newsweek article in which a neurosurgeon claimed to have discovered that “heaven is real” after his cortex “shut down.” Such journalism, these critics contend, is “shoddy,” nothing more than “simplified pop.” Additionally, publications from The Guardian to the New Statesman have published pieces blasting popular neuroscience-dependent writers like Jonah Lehrer and Malcolm Gladwell. The Oxford neuropsychologist Dorothy Bishop’s scolding lecture on the science of bad neuroscience was an online sensation last summer.
As a journalist and cultural critic, I applaud the backlash against what is sometimes called brain porn, which raises important questions about this reductionist, sloppy thinking and our willingness to accept seemingly neuroscientific explanations for, well, nearly everything.
Voting Republican? Oh, that’s brain chemistry. Success on the job? Fortuitous neurochemistry! Neuroscience has joined company with other totalizing worldviews — Marxism, Freudianism, critical theory — that have been victim to overuse and misapplication.
A team of British scientists recently analyzed nearly 3,000 neuroscientific articles published in the British press between 2000 and 2010 and found that the media regularly distorts and embellishes the findings of scientific studies. Writing in the journal Neuron, the researchers concluded that “logically irrelevant neuroscience information imbues an argument with authoritative, scientific credibility.” Another way of saying this is that bogus science gives vague, undisciplined thinking the look of seriousness and truth.

Well. There is a more than a bit of silliness in much of the pop-whatever these days: "Wisdom of the crowds" (Walmart Black Friday stampedes anyone?) and "Blink" come immediately to mind.   As well as anything David Brooks has ever written, if that qualifies.

Still...Brain's neuronal connections being plastic and all seems intuitively obvious that some people with rigid thinking - yeah, some extreme right wingers - well, their brains do seem to work differently.

And as regular readers to this site know, the author is no fan of "spiritual" "mind" "technology."  Gladwell was right about a few things, most interestingly the need to practice a lot. So yeah, be skeptical a bit. 

But then again everything is "under attack."  Dosho Port seems to be going in the direction of saying Zen is "under attack" because, hey, it seems Sasaki Roshi couldn't keep his hands to himself, and... he's still going strong at 105.

Sooner or later everything ought to be questioned,  especially Zen.   There's a crack in everything, Leonard Cohen said - it's how the light gets in.  

But keep going. 


Anonymous said...

Its my elementary in good time always to transmit on this forum,well-founded wannat recompense for some friends here.if its not allowed to record on this enter,amuse strike out this thread.Nice to fit you!

[url=]My designer handabgs[/url]

Anonymous said...

The capital is Wellington, which is really boring and windy, so don't go there unless you're a big fan of coffee, or public servants. [url=]prom Dresses uk[/url]
[url=]canada goose toronto[/url] With the lengthy time, those kinds of essentially the most frequent crimes directly threatening people today are burglary and street crime.
Gaining a parking permit required a clever ruse. [url=]Mulberry ooutlet sale[/url] Almost every season, plaid prints get hailed as the hot new trend which pretty much means they've transcended the 'trend' confines, becoming classic staples that everyone should own. If you're at a loss, ask your friends or other attendees what they think and what they will be wearing. These winners will get $250 Bed Bath Beyond Gift Card and the instant home makeover software from HGTV..
The former would include doing a Per Per Click campaign in Google Ad Words. [url=]canada goose paris[/url] They are sorted for you with your marketing system and they are more targeted..
He says that when Jobs worked at game-maker Atari they had to put him on the night shift because he walked around barefoot and never bathed, and so employees didn't want to work with him.. Some websites are affiliated with well-known brands of makeup and cosmetic items. Ladies cowboy boots are fashionable any time, any day and wearable as casual footwear or with dresses, short and long. [url=]prom ball kleider[/url]

Anonymous said...

North america Goose down hat using a strong comfortable, maybe design modified, advertising routines push grew to be Europe Moncler. [url=]Evening Dresses uk[/url]
[url=]canada goose jackets[/url] Two looks in one!.
Dre than.. [url=]Mulberry Mitzy Bags[/url] The need for the boot in colder countries was obvious, and its benefits in protecting the extremities self-evident, but the shoe - well, perhaps you had to be there. And be free to stroll on bumpy roads of life. Type in the prescription from your doctor.
The plaid options are vast and you can experiment with them simply by having the print on your umbrella or cashmere scarf. Or, maybe you have plenty of great-looking, wearable basics but you haven seen them in months because they packed away, replaced by something trendy you just bought.
Known as the carbantina, they were sandals held in place by a thong. Add a chat feature to your Internet business website to encourage your customers to converse. Stellar Jeevan is providing the exclusive vary of living choices within the kind of two, three and four BHK flats that area unit well versed with most wonderful amenities like reserved parking, lush inexperienced surroundings, communication system facility, power keep a copy, twenty four hours installation and far additional. [url=]kleider abendkleider[/url]